Crises
The 1973 to 1974 oil shock and bear market, 1971 to 1975
The post-war monetary order broke in 1971 to 1973, the first oil embargo quadrupled energy prices in late 1973, and inflation met a recession. The Nifty Fifty growth stocks bought at 40 to 90 times earnings were crushed. The S&P 500 lost 48% in 21 months and needed seven years to regain its nominal high; the UK market lost about 73%. Gold went from $35 to about $185.
The fall in numbers
- Years
- 1971 to 1975
- Index
- S&P 500
- Peak
- 11 Jan 1973
- Trough
- 3 Oct 1974
- Peak to trough
- -48.2%
- Time from peak to trough
- 21 months
- Time to recover the peak
- 69 months
- Recession
- Yes
- Regions
- US, UK, Germany, Japan
- Markets
- Equity index, Oil, Rates, Fx, Gold
In one line
Inflation plus an energy shock: the decade when neither stocks nor bonds protected savers.
What happened
The post-war monetary order broke in 1971 to 1973, the first oil embargo quadrupled energy prices in late 1973, and inflation met a recession. The Nifty Fifty growth stocks bought at 40 to 90 times earnings were crushed. The S&P 500 lost 48% in 21 months and needed seven years to regain its nominal high; the UK market lost about 73%. Gold went from $35 to about $185.
How it unfolded
Nifty Fifty and the end of fixed rates (1972-01 to 1973-03, 15 months)
Two-tier market: fifty growth stocks at 40 to 90 times earnings while the rest stagnated; inflation already rising from controls and loose policy; the dollar devalued twice.
What came next: The S&P peaked in January 1973 and had fallen 10 to 15% before the embargo; the oil shock then turned a correction into a 48% bear market.
Oil embargo (1973-04 to 1973-12, 9 months)
Stocks slid through 1973; the October embargo took oil from $3 to $12, inflation to 9% and bond yields up; the UK secondary banking crisis began.
What came next: A 1974 of stagflation: CPI 12%, recession, Franklin National and Herstatt failures, and the S&P low in October 1974 with earnings yields above bond yields.
Stagflation bear market (1974-01 to 1974-09, 9 months)
Stocks fell another third while inflation ran at double digits and bond yields rose; value destruction in real terms was 53%.
What came next: The low on 3 October 1974 came with the worst inflation print still ahead; the S&P gained 38% over the next year and regained its nominal high only in 1980.
Low with peak inflation (1974-10 to 1975-03, 6 months)
CPI peaked at 12.3% in December 1974 and the recession ended in March 1975; stocks had turned up three to five months before.
What came next: A strong 1975 (+32%) but a lost decade in real terms until 1982; gold's run continued to 1980.
Nominal recovery, real stagnation (1975-04 to 1980-07, 64 months)
Stocks rose in nominal terms but inflation ate the gains; the second oil shock in 1979 restarted the cycle.
What came next: The Volcker shock of 1979 to 1982 and the 1982 low that began the great bull market.
Key dates
| Date | Event | Stage |
|---|---|---|
| 1971-08-15 | Nixon closes the gold window | Build-up begins |
| 1973-01-11 | S&P 500 peak 120.24 | Peak |
| 1973-03 | Currencies float | Warning |
| 1973-10-17 | Oil embargo; price quadruples by January | Trigger |
| 1974-06-26 | Herstatt fails | Panic |
| 1974-10-03 | S&P low 62.28 (-48%) | Low |
| 1974-12 | CPI 12.3% | Panic |
| 1975-03 | Recession ends | Old high regained |
| 1980-07 | S&P regains the 1973 high | Old high regained |
By the numbers
- S&P 500: -48.2% from the peak to the low
- Peak to low: 21 months
- Low back to the old high: 69 months (price only)
- One year after the low: +38%
- Output, peak to trough: -3.2%
- Unemployment at its worst: 9%
What moved
- Fell: S&P -48%, UK -73%, Nifty Fifty -60 to -80% (1973-01 to 1974-10)
- Fell: bonds lost heavily in real terms as yields rose (1972 to 1974)
- Fell: Herstatt, Franklin National, UK secondary banks (1974)
- Held up or rose: gold from $35 to about $185 (1971 to 1974)
- Held up or rose: oil quadrupled; producers gained (1973-10 to 1974-01)
- Held up or rose: commodities, farmland, real assets (1972 to 1974)
Lessons the episode left
- An inflation shock hits stocks and bonds together; the 60/40 portfolio had its worst real decade.
- The equity peak came nine months before the trigger; the market was already falling when oil hit.
- Quality growth at any price (Nifty Fifty) fell as much as the junk.
- The low came near peak inflation and before the recession ended.
- Gold and commodities were the hedges; bonds were not.
What this means for a reader
Signs that were visible at the time:
- Inflation accelerating with policy still loose
- Oil doubling in a year
- Growth stocks at extreme multiples with the rest of the market stagnating
A common misreading: Waiting for inflation to fall before buying; stocks bottomed with CPI still rising.
History gives the range of what has happened, not what happens next. The numbers above are one index at one place; other markets in the same episode moved differently.
Sources
- Yergin (1991)
- Shiller data (open)
- EIA (open)
- Siegel (2014)
- FinUties crisis case file 07-bretton-woods-oil-shock-bear-1973-74.md