Glossary
Implementation shortfall
The gap between the result of a trade on paper at the decision price and the result actually achieved, including costs and unfilled quantity.
Implementation shortfall, introduced by André Perold in 1988, compares a paper portfolio traded instantly at the decision price with the real one. The difference splits into execution cost (fills worse than the decision price), opportunity cost (the part never filled) and fees.
It captures the cost of delay as well as of impact, so it is wider than the spread or the difference to VWAP.
Example: deciding to buy 10,000 shares at 50.00, filling 9,000 at an average of 50.1333 and leaving 1,000 unfilled while the price ends at 50.50 gives execution cost 1,200, opportunity cost 500 and fees 90: 1,790 in total.