FinUties 101 · The economy · Intermediate
Exchange rate regimes: floating, fixed and in between
A country chooses how its currency is priced against others. This lesson compares floating rates, fixed pegs and managed systems, and the trade-offs that decide the choice.
In this lesson
- Distinguish floating, fixed and managed exchange rate regimes
- Explain the trade-off between a fixed rate, free capital flows and independent interest rates
- Describe how a peg can come under pressure
Read first: Currencies explained: the price of one money in another, Central banks and interest rates
A currency's price against others is not always left to the market. How much a country lets it move is a policy choice, and the choice shapes inflation, trade and the risk of crises. It also explains why some exchange rates move every second and others do not move for years.
The main regimes
Floating. The rate is set by supply and demand in the currency market. The central bank does not target a level, though it may step in to calm disorderly moves. The United States, the euro area, Japan and the United Kingdom operate floating regimes. Floating rates became common after 1973, covered in floating exchange rates, 1973.
Fixed (pegged). The government commits to a set rate against another currency or a basket, and the central bank buys or sells to hold it. The best known system was Bretton Woods, 1944, which tied currencies to the dollar and the dollar to gold until 1971. See also fixed exchange rate.
Managed or crawling. The rate floats within a band, or moves along a set path, with the central bank intervening. Many emerging economies use versions of this.
Currency union. Countries share one currency, as in the euro area from 1999. It is the strongest form of a fixed rate, since the rate between members cannot change.
The impossible trinity
A country cannot have all three of these at once:
- a fixed exchange rate
- free movement of capital
- an independent monetary policy
Suppose a country pegs to the dollar, lets money move freely, and its central bank wants to cut rates to help a weak economy. Lower local rates push investors to sell the currency for dollars, which pushes it below the peg. To hold the peg, the central bank must raise rates back or spend its reserves. So it must drop one of the three. The choice differs by country.
How a peg comes under pressure
A worked example
A country pegs its currency at 10 to the dollar. Inflation at home is 8% a year and 2% in the anchor country. Prices at home rise much faster, so its goods become dearer abroad and imports become cheaper at home. The country starts to run a trade deficit. To hold the peg, the central bank sells dollars from its reserves, say 5 billion in a year, which cannot go on forever. If markets expect the peg to break, they sell the currency before it does, and reserves can fall quickly. The authorities then devalue to, say, 14 to the dollar, or let the rate float. The numbers are illustrative.
Why a country chooses a peg
- It gives importers and exporters a stable price.
- It can import credibility. A country with a record of high inflation can tie itself to a low-inflation currency.
- It makes sense when most trade is with the anchor country.
The cost is the loss of independent policy and the risk of a sudden break.
Common mistakes
- Calling a peg permanent. They have ended many times.
- Believing a floating rate is free of policy. Central banks still shape it through interest rates.
- Ignoring reserves. A peg is only as credible as the means to defend it.
In practice
When you see a currency that barely moves, find out why. If it is pegged, look at reserves, inflation compared with the anchor and how much capital can leave. Overviews of regimes are published by the International Monetary Fund.
Check yourself
What does a country give up by fixing its exchange rate and allowing free capital movement?
Control of its own interest rates. To hold the peg, its rates must follow those of the anchor country.
Why does a floating currency help absorb economic shocks?
The rate can adjust. A fall in demand for a country's exports can be met with a weaker currency, which makes exports cheaper, instead of requiring only lower wages and prices.
What happens when a central bank defends a peg and runs low on reserves?
It cannot keep selling foreign currency to support its own. If markets expect the peg to break, selling pressure grows and the authorities may have to devalue or float.