Skip to main content

Quant Analytics: from scratch to pro · Microstructure, execution and costs · Pro

Market fragility: the 2010 flash crash and the 2015 franc shock

Liquidity is thinnest when it is needed most. Two episodes, the US equity flash crash of 6 May 2010 and the end of the Swiss franc floor on 15 January 2015, show how a rule that ignores price, or a price that stops being defended, turns a thin market into a gap.

4 min read Reviewed Revision 1

In this lesson

  • Explain how a volume-linked selling rule that ignores price can feed on falling prices
  • Explain why a price floor is a promise that can end at once, and what that does to stop orders
  • Compute the gap loss of a stop order and of a leveraged position
  • List controls that limit damage from thin liquidity

Read first: Slippage and market impact: the square-root rule, Gaps and weekend risk

Worked numbers

Each result is recomputed from the formula shown.

WhatFormulaResult
share of the program sold in the first phase35000 / 7500046.7%
average value per contract4.1e9 / 7500054,667
planned loss of a stop at 98 from 100(100 - 98) / 1002%
loss when the stop fills at 90(100 - 90) / 10010%
actual loss as a multiple of the planned lossgap_loss / planned_loss5 times
illustrative gap against a position0.055%
loss on margin at 20 times leverage, small gapgap_small * 20100%
loss on margin at 20 times leverage, 8% gap0.08 * 20160%
larger illustrative gap0.088%

Check yourself

A stop order at 98 on a stock trading at 100 executes at 90 after a gap. What loss did the trader plan, and what was the loss?

Planned: 2%, from 100 to 98. Actual: 10%, from 100 to 90. The stop fixes the trigger, not the fill price.

A position uses 20 times leverage. A gap of 5% against it costs what share of the margin posted? And a gap of 8%?

5% x 20 = 100% of the margin. 8% x 20 = 160%, which is more than the margin, so the loss exceeds the money posted.

Why does a sell rule tied to 9% of recent volume behave differently from one tied to price?

Volume rises when prices fall quickly, so the rule sells faster just as the market gets thinner. A price condition could have paused it; this rule has none.

A central bank defends a floor with unlimited purchases. What risk does a trader short the floor's currency face?

The floor is a policy choice that can be dropped at once. The risk is not a gradual drift but a single large gap, and the position may be closed far from any stop level.

Name two controls that limit damage from a thin market.

Limit orders instead of stops that become market orders; size set from a gap scenario, not from the normal daily range; leverage low enough that a gap does not exceed margin.

Key terms

Market depthGapStop (stop-loss)Market impact

Checked facts

Every figure below carries how it was checked: Primary checked (read in the cited primary, official, academic or data source), Two sources agree, or Approximate (an order of magnitude only).

Sources

Crisis files

Informational content. Not investment advice.