FinUties 101 · Markets · Beginner
What a stock index is
A stock index tracks the combined value of a group of shares as one number. Most are weighted by company size. The level of an index is not a price you can pay, and a price index leaves out dividends.
In this lesson
- Calculate the change in a simple price-weighted and a market-cap-weighted index
- Explain the difference between a price index and a total return index
- Say what an index can and cannot tell you about the market
Read first: What a market is
Thousands of shares trade each day. An index turns them into one number so you can ask: how is the market doing? Headlines, funds and benchmarks all rely on indices, so it helps to know how they are built and what they leave out.
What an index is
A stock index measures the value of a chosen group of shares, set to a starting level, for example 100, on a base date. If the group's value rises 10%, the index moves from 100 to 110. The level itself has no meaning in money; only the change does.
Indices differ in what they include: a whole country's large companies, one sector, a region, or the whole world. They also differ in how they weight the members.
Price weighting
A price-weighted index adds up the share prices of its members and divides by a fixed number (the divisor). A share priced at 200 has twice the effect of one priced at 100, whatever the size of the company. The Dow Jones average works this way; see the Dow Jones average, 1896.
Example: three shares priced at 100, 50 and 30. The sum is 180. If the 100 share rises 10% (to 110) and the others do not move, the sum is 190, up 5.6%. If the 30 share rises 10% (to 33), the sum is 183, up 1.7%. The same percent move has a different effect only because of the price level.
Market-cap weighting
Most modern indices use market capitalisation: share price times number of shares in issue. A company with 1 billion shares at 50 has a market capitalisation of 50 billion. In a market-cap-weighted index, each member counts in proportion to that value.
Example: companies A (market cap 600), B (300) and C (100). Weights are 60%, 30% and 10%. If A rises 10%, B falls 5% and C is unchanged: index change = 0.6 x 10% + 0.3 x (-5%) + 0.1 x 0% = 6% - 1.5% = 4.5%. Large companies dominate, which can mean that a few firms drive an index.
Some indices give each company the same weight (equal-weighted) or choose weights by other rules. The rule matters: two indices of the same companies can behave differently.
Price index and total return index
A price index tracks share prices only. A total return index assumes dividends are paid out and reinvested. Over long periods the difference can be large, because dividends are part of what shareholders earn. Robert Shiller's public data set gives both the price and the dividends for the US market since 1871, which is why it is used for long-run work. See also how to read financial history.
What indices are used for
- Gauge: a quick view of whether markets are up or down.
- Benchmark: a standard to compare a fund or a portfolio against.
- Basis for funds: index funds and exchange-traded funds hold the index members; see the first index fund.
Limits
- An index is a rule, with its own choices: who joins, who leaves, how weights are set. Members that did badly may be removed, which flatters the history.
- The level cannot be bought. Only products tracking it can, with costs.
- It describes the past, not the future.
- "The market" in a headline is usually one index, and other indices may tell a different story.
Common mistakes
- Treating a high index level as expensive and a low one as cheap. The level depends on the base date and the divisor.
- Comparing a price index with a total return index.
- Assuming a country's index equals its economy.
- Ignoring concentration when a few members make up most of the weight.
In practice
When you read "the index fell 2%", ask which index, price or total return, and how it is weighted. On FinUties, Analytics shows market state across indices and other assets.
Check yourself
In a market-cap-weighted index, which company has more effect on the index: one worth 500 billion or one worth 5 billion?
The 500 billion one. Each company's influence is proportional to its market capitalisation, so a 1% move in the larger company moves the index 100 times as much.
An index of 100 rises to 110 and pays 2% in dividends over the year. Which return does the price index show?
10%. The price index ignores dividends. A total return index would show about 12%.
Can you buy 'the index' directly?
Not directly. An index is a calculation. You can buy funds that hold the same shares in the same weights. See the lessons on funds.
Key terms
Sources
- Online data: U.S. stock markets 1871-present and CAPE ratio. Robert J. Shiller, Yale University. Accessed 8 Nov 2026