FinUties 101 · Risk · Beginner
What risk means in investing
Risk is the chance that the outcome is worse than you planned, not only the chance of losing money. Four kinds of risk, and the difference between a swing you can wait out and a loss you cannot recover from.
In this lesson
- Define risk as the spread of possible outcomes, not only the chance of a loss
- Tell price swings apart from permanent loss of capital
- Name four common kinds of risk and give one example of each
Read first: Risk and return
Everyone who invests takes risk, but the word is used loosely. For some it means "I could lose money". For others it means "the price moves a lot". Both ideas matter, and they are not the same. A clear meaning of risk is the base for every other lesson in this track.
Risk is a range, not a single number
Suppose you put 1,000 into something and expect it to be worth about 1,100 in a year. That is your plan. Risk is the possibility that the result differs from the plan: it can be 1,300 or 700. The wider the range of results you can reasonably imagine, the higher the risk.
This is why risk and return are linked. An asset with a narrow range of outcomes, such as a short-term government bond, pays little. An asset with a wide range, such as a share in a young company, has to offer a higher possible return to attract buyers. The lesson risk and return builds on this.
Swings versus permanent loss
Prices fall and rise. A fall that later reverses is a swing. A loss is permanent when the money does not come back. There are three common ways to turn a swing into a permanent loss:
- You sell at the low, often because the fall frightened you.
- The asset never recovers, for example because the company fails.
- You are forced to sell, because you borrowed and the lender demands repayment or because you need the cash.
Take a worked example. An index fund falls from 100 to 70 in a bad year, a fall of 30%. The investor who holds and does not need the money has an unrealised loss. The investor who borrowed half of the purchase price may be forced to sell near 70 and keeps the loss. The market did the same thing to both. The difference was what each could survive.
History shows how large swings can be. The US stock market fell about 89% in the Great Depression and took about 25 years from its 1929 peak to regain it, while the 2020 fall of 34% was recovered within five months of the low. See the 1929 crash and the COVID crash. Both were swings; only one was long enough to break most borrowers and many savers.
Four kinds of risk
- Market risk. The whole market moves against you. Diversifying across shares does not remove it.
- Specific risk. One company, sector or country does badly. Spreading across many holdings reduces it.
- Counterparty and credit risk. The other side of a promise fails: a borrower does not repay, a bank fails, a broker cannot deliver.
- Liquidity risk. You cannot sell at a fair price when you need to, because buyers disappear or the spread widens.
Two more are worth knowing early. Inflation risk is that money keeps its number but buys less. Behavioural risk is that your own reaction, selling in panic or chasing a rally, costs more than the market does.
Measuring what you can
Some risk can be measured. Volatility measures how much prices move. Drawdown measures how far an account falls from its high. Both describe the past and are useful, but neither tells you the worst that can happen.
Common mistakes
- Treating a low-volatility asset as having no risk. Quiet prices can hide a large, rare loss.
- Treating all falls as equal. A fall you can wait out is different from a loss that ends your plan.
- Judging a decision only by its result. A good decision can lose and a poor one can win; look at the range of outcomes you accepted.
- Ignoring the size of the position. The same asset is a small risk at 2% of savings and a large one at 80%.
In practice
Before any commitment, ask three questions: how bad could it get, how long could it last, and could I stay in through it. The answer to the third decides whether a swing stays a swing. The Research area of FinUties publishes studies of past episodes that show how deep and how long falls have been.
Check yourself
A share falls 30% and then recovers fully within a year. Did the holder lose money?
Only if they sold at the low. The fall was a temporary swing on paper. A loss becomes permanent when you sell, when the company fails, or when you are forced to sell because you borrowed or needed the cash.
Why is 'the chance of losing money' an incomplete definition of risk?
Because it ignores how much you could lose and how likely a bad outcome is compared with your plan. Two investments can each have a one-in-four chance of a loss while one loses 5% and the other 60%.
Which kind of risk is a bank failing while you hold a deposit there?
Counterparty (or credit) risk: the other side of a promise does not keep it.
Key terms
Sources
- Triumph of the Optimists: 101 Years of Global Investment Returns. Princeton University Press (Elroy Dimson, Paul Marsh, Mike Staunton), 2002