FinUties 101 · Investing · Beginner
Diversification: not keeping everything in one place
Diversification spreads money across holdings that do not move together, so no single failure decides the outcome. It lowers the risk of a portfolio without a matching cut in expected return, but it cannot remove market-wide losses.
In this lesson
- Explain why holding several investments can lower risk
- Tell diversification across holdings from owning many similar holdings
- Describe what diversification cannot protect against
Putting all your money in one company means one piece of bad news can damage your savings. Diversification is the practice of spreading money across different holdings so that no single one decides the result. It is one of the few ideas in investing that lowers risk without a matching drop in what you can expect to earn, which is why it is taught first.
The basic idea
An investment's value moves up and down. Two investments rarely move in exactly the same way. If one falls while the other rises or stays flat, the total moves less than either part. This is the whole mechanism. The less two holdings move together, the more they smooth each other.
How much two holdings move together is measured by correlation, a number between -1 and 1. At 1 they move in lockstep and combining them helps nothing. Below 1, combining them reduces the swings. The economist Harry Markowitz set this out formally; see Markowitz and portfolio selection, 1952.
A worked example
Take two businesses with simple illustrative outcomes. An umbrella seller earns 10 units in a wet year and 2 in a dry year. A sunscreen seller earns 2 in a wet year and 10 in a dry year. Each business on its own earns 10 or 2 depending on the weather: a wide swing.
Now put half your money in each. In a wet year you receive half of 10 plus half of 2, which is 6. In a dry year you receive half of 2 plus half of 10, which is also 6. The result is 6 in both cases, the same as the average of either business alone if wet and dry years are equally likely, but the swing has gone. Real holdings are never this perfectly opposite, so the reduction is smaller, but the direction is the same.
Two kinds of risk
- Specific risk belongs to one company or one asset: a failed product, a fraud, a lawsuit. Holding many unrelated holdings dilutes it quickly.
- Market risk is shared by almost everything: a recession, a rate shock, a credit crisis. Holding more shares does not remove it.
This is why the first few holdings help a lot and the hundredth helps very little. Once specific risk is spread out, what is left is mostly market risk.
How people diversify
- Across companies: many shares instead of a handful.
- Across sectors and countries: so one industry or one economy does not dominate.
- Across asset types: shares, bonds, cash and others, which respond differently to growth and to interest rates. This is covered in asset allocation.
- Through funds: a broad index fund holds hundreds or thousands of securities in one product. See the first index fund.
Common mistakes
- Counting names instead of risks. Ten funds that all hold the same large companies are one bet.
- Assuming holdings that were unrelated in calm markets stay unrelated in a crisis. Correlations often rise when markets fall; see correlation and its limits.
- Diversifying so widely that you cannot understand what you hold.
- Believing diversification guarantees a gain. It reduces one type of risk; losses still happen, and a drawdown can still be deep.
In practice
Ask of any portfolio: what single event would hurt most of this at once? If the answer is short, such as one sector or one currency, the portfolio is less diversified than its number of holdings suggests. Analytics on FinUties shows market state across several areas, which can help you see how different markets are behaving.
Check yourself
Why does holding two investments usually give a smoother ride than holding one?
Because they rarely fall and rise by the same amount on the same days. When one is down, the other is often flat or up, so the combined value moves less than either part alone.
A portfolio holds 30 technology shares from one country. Is it well diversified?
Only weakly. The holdings differ in name but share the same main risks: the same sector, the same economy and similar investor moods. They tend to fall together.
Can diversification prevent a loss in a market-wide fall?
No. It reduces the risk tied to one holding, but the risk shared by almost everything cannot be diversified away. In severe stress, many holdings fall together.