Australian home loans post record fall as New Zealand property losses rise
By FinUties Research · · 11 min read · Research
Australia recorded its sharpest quarterly drop in new home loans, led by investors, while Cotality data show a growing share of New Zealand properties being sold at a loss. Both markets are weak, though the causes and official reactions differ.
What happened
Australian Bureau of Statistics figures show a record 15% quarterly fall in new home loans in the September quarter [1]. Investor loans dropped 31%, against a 5% decline for owner-occupiers [1]. Nationwide house prices have fallen 6.7% from their March peak, which Cotality describes as the fastest decline in 40 years [1].
The political reading is split. Housing Minister Clare O'Neil welcomed the investor-heavy decline as consistent with tax changes in the May budget [1]. The opposition, property groups and Master Builders Australia instead blame negative gearing and capital gains reforms, together with rate hikes, for damaging confidence [1].
Across the Tasman, Cotality's latest Pain and Gain report shows 15.8% of New Zealand properties sold in the quarter went for less than the owner paid [2]. That is the highest loss share in 14 years, apart from the third quarter of 2021 [2]. Auckland had the highest loss rate at 25.5% [2]. Among those who made a loss, the median loss was $60,000, while the median gain among profitable sales was $270,000 [2].
Cotality chief economist Kelvin Davidson attributes the New Zealand result to values sitting below their peak, heavy listings that favour purchasers, uncertain economic conditions and higher mortgage rates [2]. He does not describe it as a new price crash [2].
How we got here
New Zealand's market has been soft for some time. On 24 September, Cotality expected six to nine more months of a flat market [3]. August sales fell 11.6 percent year on year to 6175 deals, the eighth consecutive monthly decline, and nationwide values were down 18 percent from peak [3]. Davidson said Labour's commitment not to reintroduce the phased-out interest deductibility ban could reduce investor uncertainty and support a gradual return, but he did not expect a rush [3]. He cited job security concerns, flat rents, higher council rates and insurance, and capital gains tax on the radar [3].
On 1 October, Cotality's September data showed values down 0.3% to a national median of $797,078 [4]. Owner-occupiers moving between homes were taking longer to complete sales than investors, which suggests reluctance to cut prices [4]. Purchasers kept negotiating power amid economic uncertainty and election-related caution, although affordability gains and active first-home purchasers supported parts of the market [4].
On 29 October, a Cotality and Westpac report put first-home purchasers at a record 29.5% share of New Zealand purchases [5]. Economists linked easier access to the ladder to inventory, lower rates than the 2023 peaks, and cautious investors and owner-occupiers, while affordability remained difficult and deal volumes may be softening [5].
On 4 November, Cotality reported that prices fell 0.4% in October, the seventh straight monthly decline [6]. The national median was $790,987 and values were 2.3% below a year earlier [6]. Nominal prices rose about 34.7% over ten years while inflation rose roughly 34%, so prices barely moved in real terms [6]. Davidson said sluggish sales and prices were possible for 12–18 months, with purchasers retaining bargaining power [6].
Tax policy was also in the political debate. Opportunity party leader Qiulae Wong proposes a land-value tax and a universal Citizen's Income of $NZ370 per week, a plan Prime Minister Christopher Luxon rejects [7]. Polls put her party at 6–8%, and crossing the 5% threshold could give it a kingmaker role if neither major coalition wins a majority [7].
What changed is that the Australian data add a policy-linked shock to a market whose 6.7% fall is measured from a peak set only in March [1]. In New Zealand, the shift is from months of falling prices and sales to a rising share of loss-making resales [2][3][6].
Why it matters for markets
In Australia, a 31% fall in investor loans could mean less demand from a group directly affected by tax settings, and the dispute over negative gearing, capital gains reforms and rate hikes shows the causes are contested [1]. If the investor retreat persisted, it could keep pressure on prices, though it is not yet known how long the pullback will last [1].
In New Zealand, a higher share of loss-making resales could weigh on owners who purchased near the peak, and it could affect willingness to list [2][4]. Davidson's view that this is not a new crash suggests the loss share reflects the earlier decline rather than a fresh drop [2]. No direct channel to bond yields or currencies is apparent in either country.
What to watch
- Whether Australian investor loan volumes stabilise or fall further after the 31% drop, and whether the 5% owner-occupier decline deepens [1].
- Any Australian policy response to the competing claims about the May budget tax changes and rate hikes [1].
- Cotality's next monthly New Zealand values after seven straight declines, and whether the 0.4% October fall is repeated [6].
- Whether the Pain and Gain loss share stays near 15.8%, and whether Auckland's 25.5% rate changes [2].
- New Zealand's election outcome and any tax policy, including land-value or capital gains measures, that follows; it is not yet known whether Opportunity won seats [7].
- Whether investors return gradually to New Zealand, as Davidson thought possible but not rapid [3].
Sources
- Top Stories: Sharpest home loan drop on record as property investors exit market, 11 Nov 2026
- RNZ News Headlines: Property sellers losing money at rate not seen in 14 years, property data firm says, 11 Nov 2026
- RNZ News Headlines: Six to nine months more of flat housing market, Cotality says, 24 Sep 2026
- RNZ News Headlines: Moving homeowners holding on longer for the right price, 01 Oct 2026
- RNZ News Headlines: What a typical first-home buyer looks like now, 29 Oct 2026
- RNZ News Headlines: House prices haven't moved in real terms in a decade, 04 Nov 2026
- Top Stories: Newcomer's meteoric rise could make her NZ election's 'kingmaker', 04 Nov 2026
FinUties generates this briefing for transparency. Published after editorial review. It may summarize source data and does not provide investment recommendations. Data availability at one timestamp does not guarantee future continuity.
Provenance
- Study:
event-desk-20261111-australian-home-loans-post-record-fall-as-new-zealand-proper(51919d07-2bd5-4f44-98bd-d402a3ffa97f) - Author: FinUties Research
- Approved by: FinUties Research at 2026-11-12T00:28:10.456212Z
- Kind: event brief (news sources, not a FinUties dataset study)
- Cited sources: 7 from 2 outlets, all licensed for public use
-
Earlier related events cited from 2026-09-24
-
Manifest:
/api/v1/research/studies/event-desk-20261111-australian-home-loans-post-record-fall-as-new-zealand-proper/manifest - Replay tolerance: append_only_sources
More research
Join the waitlist More research RSS feed Pricing About
Informational only — not investment advice. Research briefs from the FinUties research desk; data availability can change with upstream sources.