Crises
The Q4 2018 sell-off, 2018 to 2019
After a record on 20 September 2018 the S&P 500 fell 19.8% to 24 December, the worst December since 1931. Causes cited: four Fed hikes in 2018 and balance-sheet reduction 'on autopilot', the US-China trade war, a government shutdown, a Chinese slowdown and a technology sell-off. On 4 January 2019 the Fed chair said it would be patient; the S&P rose 29% in 2019 and the Fed cut three times.
The fall in numbers
- Years
- 2018 to 2019
- Index
- S&P 500
- Peak
- 20 Sep 2018
- Trough
- 24 Dec 2018
- Peak to trough
- -19.8%
- Time from peak to trough
- 3.0 months
- Time to recover the peak
- 4.0 months
- Recession
- Yes
- Regions
- US, China
- Markets
- Equity index, Rates, Credit hy
In one line
A 20% fall ended by a change of tone at the Fed.
What happened
After a record on 20 September 2018 the S&P 500 fell 19.8% to 24 December, the worst December since 1931. Causes cited: four Fed hikes in 2018 and balance-sheet reduction 'on autopilot', the US-China trade war, a government shutdown, a Chinese slowdown and a technology sell-off. On 4 January 2019 the Fed chair said it would be patient; the S&P rose 29% in 2019 and the Fed cut three times.
How it unfolded
Late-cycle tightening (2018-03 to 2018-09, 7 months)
Fed hikes and QT, the 10-year at 3.2%, trade tariffs, EM stress (Turkey, Argentina), housing slowing, the yield curve flattening.
What came next: A 20% fall in three months with high-yield issuance closing in December.
Autopilot (2018-10 to 2018-12, 3 months)
Two 10% legs, a Christmas Eve capitulation on a half day, zero high-yield issuance in December, oil -40%.
What came next: The Fed's reversal in January ended it; new highs in April 2019 and three cuts later in the year.
Fed pivot (2019-01 to 2019-04, 4 months)
Patience, then cuts; a 25% rally in four months.
What came next: The repo spike in September 2019 and the 2020 crash.
Key dates
| Date | Event | Stage |
|---|---|---|
| 2018-09-20 | S&P record 2,931 | Peak |
| 2018-10-03 | 'Long way from neutral' | Trigger |
| 2018-12-19 | Fourth 2018 hike; 'autopilot' remark | Panic |
| 2018-12-24 | S&P low 2,351 (-19.8%) | Low |
| 2019-01-04 | Fed: patient | Policy turn |
| 2019-04-23 | Record regained | Old high regained |
By the numbers
- S&P 500: -19.8% from the peak to the low
- Peak to low: 3 months
- Low back to the old high: 4 months (price only)
- One year after the low: +37%
What moved
- Fell: S&P -19.8%; Nasdaq -23% (2018-09 to 2018-12)
- Fell: WTI $76 to $42 (2018-10 to 2018-12)
- Fell: high-yield spreads +200 bp; primary market closed (2018-12)
- Held up or rose: Treasuries: 10-year 3.2% to 2.6% (2018-11 to 2019-01)
Lessons the episode left
- Tightening into slowing growth produced a near-bear market without a recession.
- Credit markets closing (zero issuance) marked the low.
- The reversal was a sentence from the Fed; the cushion existed because inflation was at target.
What this means for a reader
Signs that were visible at the time:
- Central bank hiking while the curve flattens and oil falls
- High-yield issuance stopping
A common misreading: Assuming the Fed can always pivot; it could because inflation was 2%.
History gives the range of what has happened, not what happens next. The numbers above are one index at one place; other markets in the same episode moved differently.
Sources
- Fed statements
- EIA, VIX, 10y (open)
- FinUties crisis case file 24-other-episodes.md