Crises
China's stock bust, the oil collapse and the 2015 to 2016 growth scare, 2014 to 2016
Saudi Arabia chose market share over price in November 2014 and crude fell 75% against a surge of US shale supply. China's margin-financed stock boom (Shanghai up 150% in a year) collapsed from June 2015, and a surprise yuan devaluation in August convinced the world that China's slowdown was worse than reported. Global stocks had their worst start to a year on record in January 2016, oil hit $26 and high-yield energy credit stopped functioning.
The fall in numbers
- Years
- 2014 to 2016
- Index
- S&P 500 (Shanghai -49%)
- Peak
- 12 Jun 2015
- Trough
- 11 Feb 2016
- Peak to trough
- -14.2%
- Time from peak to trough
- 9.0 months
- Time to recover the peak
- 5.0 months
- Recession
- No
- Regions
- China, US, oil exporters, global
- Markets
- Oil, Equity index, Fx em, Credit hy
In one line
Oil fell 75%, China's stocks halved, and the S&P lost 14%.
What happened
Saudi Arabia chose market share over price in November 2014 and crude fell 75% against a surge of US shale supply. China's margin-financed stock boom (Shanghai up 150% in a year) collapsed from June 2015, and a surprise yuan devaluation in August convinced the world that China's slowdown was worse than reported. Global stocks had their worst start to a year on record in January 2016, oil hit $26 and high-yield energy credit stopped functioning. A coordinated policy response and an OPEC cut ended it; the S&P fell 14% at most.
How it unfolded
Oil glut and a margin-financed boom (2014-07 to 2015-05, 11 months)
Shale added 4 million barrels a day; OPEC abandoned price defence; oil halved by January 2015 while China's retail investors borrowed to chase a state-cheered stock market up 150%.
What came next: The Shanghai peak in June 2015 and the yuan devaluation in August turned a commodity story into a global growth scare.
China devaluation and growth scare (2015-06 to 2016-02, 9 months)
Shanghai -49% with 1,400 stocks halted and $3.4 trillion lost; China spent $800 billion of reserves; EM currencies fell 20 to 40%; high-yield energy spreads passed 1,500 bp; the S&P had two 12 to 14% drops with an August flash crash and the worst January on record.
What came next: The low on 11 February 2016 came with oil at $26; the dollar stopped rising, China's outflows slowed, the Fed paused for a year and the S&P was at a record in July 2016.
Policy pause and oil floor (2016-03 to 2016-07, 5 months)
G20 coordination, Chinese stimulus, the Fed on hold, oil doubling from the low.
What came next: A record S&P by July 2016, then the reflation trade; shale survived and OPEC cut in November 2016.
Reflation (2016-08 to 2017-12, 17 months)
Synchronised global growth, low volatility, record highs.
What came next: Volmageddon in February 2018 and the Q4 2018 sell-off as the Fed tightened.
Key dates
| Date | Event | Stage |
|---|---|---|
| 2014-06 | WTI peak $108; Shanghai boom begins | Build-up begins |
| 2014-11-27 | OPEC declines to cut | Trigger |
| 2015-06-12 | Shanghai peak 5,166 | Peak |
| 2015-08-11 | Yuan fixing change; -4.5% in three days | Trigger |
| 2015-08-24 | Black Monday: S&P -4%, VIX 53 intraday, DJIA -1,089 at the open | Panic |
| 2015-12-16 | First Fed hike since 2006 | Warning |
| 2016-01-04 | Chinese circuit breakers; worst start to a year | Panic |
| 2016-02-11 | WTI $26; S&P low 1,829 (-14%) | Low |
| 2016-02-26 | G20 Shanghai; policy coordination | Policy turn |
| 2016-11-30 | OPEC+ cut | Old high regained |
By the numbers
- S&P 500 (Shanghai -49%): -14.2% from the peak to the low
- Peak to low: 9 months
- Low back to the old high: 5 months (price only)
- One year after the low: +27%
- USD/CNY (6.2 to 7.0 by 2016-12): -13%
What moved
- Fell: WTI $108 to $26 (2014-06 to 2016-02)
- Fell: Shanghai -49%; S&P -14%; EM equities -35% (2015-06 to 2016-02)
- Fell: ruble -50%, real -45%, rand -35% (2014 to 2016)
- Fell: energy high yield defaults; Third Avenue fund gated Dec 2015 (2015 to 2016)
- Held up or rose: US dollar +25% trade weighted 2014 to 2016 (2014-07 to 2016-01)
- Held up or rose: Treasuries and Bunds; 10-year yield to 1.6% (2015 to 2016)
- Held up or rose: gold +20% in early 2016 (2016-01 to 2016-07)
Lessons the episode left
- A supply-driven oil collapse is a growth scare for exporters and credit, and a tax cut for importers; the net equity effect was small.
- Margin-financed retail booms end in halts and forced selling (1,400 stocks suspended).
- A surprise currency regime change by a large economy moves everything.
- The growth scare ended when the dollar stopped rising.
What this means for a reader
Signs that were visible at the time:
- A strong dollar together with a commodity collapse
- Credit stress concentrated in one sector
A common misreading: Trading the S&P as if it were an oil exporter.
History gives the range of what has happened, not what happens next. The numbers above are one index at one place; other markets in the same episode moved differently.
Sources
- EIA (open)
- IMF WEO (2016)
- Fed H.10 (open)
- FinUties crisis case file 20-china-and-oil-collapse-2014-16.md