Crises
Russia's default and LTCM (1998)
The Asian crisis pushed commodity prices down and capital out of emerging markets. In August 1998 Russia devalued the ruble, defaulted on domestic debt and froze foreign payments. The shock hit every relative-value trade at once: Long-Term Capital Management, with $4.7 billion of capital and a $125 billion balance sheet, lost $4.6 billion in four months and was wound down by 14 banks convened by the New York Fed.
The fall in numbers
- Years
- 1998
- Index
- S&P 500
- Peak
- 17 Jul 1998
- Trough
- 8 Oct 1998
- Peak to trough
- -19.3%
- Time from peak to trough
- 3.0 months
- Time to recover the peak
- 2.0 months
- Recession
- No
- Regions
- Russia, US, global credit
- Markets
- Sovereign debt, Rates, Credit, Fx, Equity index
In one line
The default that nearly broke Wall Street through one hedge fund.
What happened
The Asian crisis pushed commodity prices down and capital out of emerging markets. In August 1998 Russia devalued the ruble, defaulted on domestic debt and froze foreign payments. The shock hit every relative-value trade at once: Long-Term Capital Management, with $4.7 billion of capital and a $125 billion balance sheet, lost $4.6 billion in four months and was wound down by 14 banks convened by the New York Fed. The S&P fell 19%, Treasuries rallied hard and the Fed cut three times.
How it unfolded
Convergence trades at maximum leverage (1998-01 to 1998-07, 7 months)
Hedge funds and bank desks held the same relative-value positions at 25:1 leverage; Russia financed deficits with GKOs at 50 to 150% yields; oil fell to $12 and Asian contagion continued; the S&P hit a record in July.
What came next: The Russian default in August caused a flight to quality that moved every spread against the crowded positions at once.
Default and the LTCM unwind (1998-08 to 1998-10, 3 months)
Ruble -70%, Russian stocks -93%, EM spreads +1,000 bp, swap and mortgage spreads at records, the S&P -19%, the 10-year yield down to 4.2%, the yen carry trade unwound 15% in three days; the Fed convened the LTCM rescue and cut rates.
What came next: Recovery within weeks: the S&P regained its high in late November and the Nasdaq rose 86% in 1999; the Fed's cuts fed the dot-com mania.
Fast recovery into mania (1998-11 to 1999-06, 8 months)
Three Fed cuts, record highs within two months, a technology melt-up.
What came next: The dot-com peak in March 2000.
Key dates
| Date | Event | Stage |
|---|---|---|
| 1997-10 | Russian stocks peak; oil falling | Build-up begins |
| 1998-07-13 | IMF package of $22.6 billion for Russia | Warning |
| 1998-07-17 | S&P 500 peak 1,186.75 | Peak |
| 1998-08-17 | Russia devalues and defaults | Trigger |
| 1998-08-21 | LTCM loses $550 million in a day | Panic |
| 1998-09-23 | Fed-brokered $3.6 billion recapitalisation of LTCM | Policy turn |
| 1998-09-29 | First of three Fed cuts | Policy turn |
| 1998-10-08 | S&P low about 957 (-19%); yen +15% in three days | Low |
| 1998-11-23 | S&P back at its high | Old high regained |
By the numbers
- S&P 500: -19.3% from the peak to the low
- Peak to low: 3 months
- Low back to the old high: 2 months (price only)
- One year after the low: +38%
- USD/RUB: -70%
What moved
- Fell: ruble -70% (1998-08 to 1999-01)
- Fell: every spread product: swap, mortgage, EM, high yield (1998-08 to 1998-10)
- Fell: S&P -19%; Russia -93% (1998-07 to 1998-10)
- Fell: Brent to $9 to $10 (1998-12)
- Held up or rose: Treasuries: 10-year yield 5.5% to 4.2% (1998-07 to 1998-10)
- Held up or rose: yen +15% in three days as carry trades unwound (1998-10-06)
Lessons the episode left
- Diversification across markets fails when the same leveraged holders own all of them.
- Liquidity, not valuation, drove the losses: spreads widened because everyone sold the same things.
- A sovereign default in a small economy can threaten the core through one over-leveraged intermediary.
- The rescue was private money convened by the central bank; the Fed cuts did the rest.
- The policy response fed the next bubble.
What this means for a reader
Signs that were visible at the time:
- Spreads widening across unrelated markets at the same time
- A sharp carry-currency rally (yen) as leverage unwinds
A common misreading: Reading the 19% fall as the start of a bear market; the index was at a record 60 days after the low.
History gives the range of what has happened, not what happens next. The numbers above are one index at one place; other markets in the same episode moved differently.
Sources
- Lowenstein (2000)
- President's Working Group (1999)
- Jorion (2000)
- FinUties crisis case file 15-russia-and-ltcm-1998.md