FinUties 101 · Investing · Intermediate
Investor behaviour: the part of the portfolio that is you
Many investment mistakes are behavioural: selling in a panic, chasing recent winners, trading too often. Knowing the common biases and agreeing rules with yourself in calm conditions reduces them.
In this lesson
- Name four common behavioural biases and how each shows up
- Explain why a plan written in advance helps in a falling market
- Recognise how behaviour can change the return an investor actually receives
Read first: Asset allocation: deciding the mix, Costs and fees: what you keep
Knowing what to do is easier than doing it. Prices fall, headlines worry, and a plan that looked sensible in calm conditions is hard to keep. Behavioural finance studies how real people depart from the textbook investor. Understanding the patterns does not make you immune, but it helps you design around them.
Common biases
- Loss aversion: a loss hurts more than an equal gain pleases. People hold losers hoping to get back to even and sell winners early to lock in a feeling of success.
- Recency bias: giving too much weight to what happened lately. After a long rise, risk feels low. After a fall, it feels permanent.
- Herding: following the crowd because others seem to know something. Crowds are loud at tops and bottoms. The dot-com boom and the global financial crisis both show crowds moving together.
- Overconfidence: believing your skill or information is better than it is. It leads to too much trading and too little diversification.
- Anchoring: fixing on a number, such as the price you paid, which the market does not care about.
A worked example of behaviour costing money
A fund starts at 100. It falls 30% to 70 and later recovers to 100. A holder who stays in ends where they began, with 100. Another holder sells at 70, afraid of more falls, and buys back only when the fund has climbed to 90, once the news feels better. Their 70 buys 70 / 90 of a unit, which grows to about 77.8 when the fund reaches 100. They locked in the fall and missed most of the recovery. The fund's return and the investor's return are different numbers, and the gap is behaviour.
Note that recovery time varies and is never certain. A fall can last longer, or never fully reverse. The point is that decisions made out of panic are made at the worst moment of discomfort, not that waiting always works. See drawdowns and recovery maths.
Designing around yourself
- Write a plan in calm conditions: target mix, how often you review, and what would make you change it. See asset allocation.
- Automate: regular contributions and scheduled rebalancing take emotion out of the timing.
- Size your risk to your nerves: choose a mix whose worst plausible fall you could sit through.
- Limit your inputs: checking prices daily raises the number of moments when fear can act.
- Keep a decision journal: write down why you acted. Later you can see what your reasons were worth.
Common mistakes
- Believing you are the exception to these biases.
- Changing the plan in the middle of a fall because it feels different this time. See what repeats in booms and busts.
- Treating a plan as a prediction. It is a set of rules for acting without knowing the future.
In practice
Before any significant decision, ask: would I make this choice if the price had not moved this week? If the answer is no, the price is deciding, not the plan. Research on FinUties publishes studies on market behaviour.
Check yourself
What is loss aversion?
The tendency to feel a loss more strongly than a gain of the same size. It can push people to sell after a fall to stop the discomfort, locking in the loss.
Why can an investor earn less than the fund they hold?
If they buy after prices have risen and sell after they have fallen, their money is invested during the poor stretches and missing during the recoveries, so their own return differs from the fund's return.
How does a written plan help?
It is made when you are calm. In a fall, you follow a rule you agreed with yourself instead of deciding under stress.