FinUties 101 · Investing · Intermediate
Valuation basics: price versus value
Valuation compares what an asset costs with what it earns or pays. The price-earnings ratio is the simplest tool, and it is useful only when you know what it leaves out.
In this lesson
- Calculate and read a price-earnings ratio
- Explain what a high or low ratio can and cannot tell you
- Name the limits of valuation measures as timing tools
Read first: Diversification: not keeping everything in one place, Costs and fees: what you keep, Shares explained: owning a piece of a company
A price tells you what something costs. Valuation asks what you receive for that price. Two shares both priced at 50 can be very different deals if one company earns five times what the other earns. Valuation measures put price and earnings, or price and another business figure, on one scale so that they can be compared.
The price-earnings ratio
The price-earnings ratio (P/E) divides the share price by the company's earnings per share over a year.
If a share costs 50 and earnings are 2.50 per share, the ratio is 20. Put another way, the earnings yield is 2.50 / 50, or 5%: each unit invested is backed by 0.05 of yearly profit. A lower ratio means more earnings for the price, all else equal.
What the ratio leaves out
A P/E of 10 is not automatically a bargain, and 30 is not automatically dear. The ratio depends on:
- Growth: investors pay more for earnings expected to grow. A fast-growing company can have a high ratio and still be reasonably priced if growth arrives.
- Quality and risk: stable, low-debt businesses often trade on higher ratios than fragile ones.
- Interest rates: when rates on safe bonds are high, future earnings are worth less today, which tends to lower what investors pay.
- Unusual earnings: a one-off gain makes the ratio look low; a temporary loss makes it look high or meaningless.
- Accounting choices and sector: ratios differ by industry. Compare a company with its own history and with similar companies.
A worked example
Company X: price 60, earnings per share 4, so P/E 15. Company Y: price 60, earnings per share 2, so P/E 30. Y looks twice as expensive. But if Y's earnings are expected to double over a few years while X's stay flat, then on those future earnings both would cost the same. The ratio is a starting point for the question "what is already expected?", not an answer.
Smoothing the cycle
Earnings swing with the economy, which makes a single-year P/E noisy. The CAPE ratio divides price by average inflation-adjusted earnings over ten years to reduce this. Robert Shiller's public data set publishes it for the US market. See also how valuations looked in the dot-com episode.
Common mistakes
- Using valuation as a timing tool. Expensive markets have stayed expensive for long periods, and cheap ones cheaper.
- Comparing ratios across industries or countries without context.
- Using a ratio built on one unusual year of earnings.
- Forgetting that a ratio describes a price level, not a promise of return.
In practice
Use valuation to ask what a price already assumes. If it assumes high growth for many years, the risk of disappointment is higher. If it assumes little, the risk is lower, though not absent. Research on FinUties publishes studies of long-run market data.
Check yourself
A share costs 50 and the company earned 2.50 per share last year. What is the price-earnings ratio?
50 divided by 2.50 is 20. You pay 20 units of price for each 1 unit of yearly earnings.
Does a low price-earnings ratio mean a share is cheap?
Not by itself. The market may expect earnings to fall, or this year's earnings may be unusually high. A low ratio is a question to investigate, not a conclusion.
Why is a valuation measure a weak tool for timing the next month?
Markets can stay expensive or cheap for years. Valuation relates to long-run returns and risk, not to what prices do next.