Crises
The euro sovereign debt crisis (2010 to 2012), 2009 to 2015
In its first decade the euro lowered borrowing costs for weaker members, which borrowed heavily. When 2008 exposed these debts, bond markets began to price default, and because banks held their governments' bonds and governments guaranteed the banks, the two fed each other. Greece, Ireland, Portugal, Cyprus and the Spanish banks were rescued; Italy and Spain came close to losing market access. Draghi's 'whatever it takes' in July 2012 ended the acute phase.
The fall in numbers
- Years
- 2009 to 2015
- Index
- Euro Stoxx 50 (about -35% 2011); Athens -90%
- Peak
- May 2010
- Trough
- 6 Sep 2012
- Peak to trough
- -35.0%
- Time from peak to trough
- 15 months
- Recession
- Yes
- Regions
- Greece, Ireland, Portugal, Spain, Italy, Cyprus, euro area
- Markets
- Sovereign debt, Banks, Fx, Equity index
In one line
Countries that could not print their own money found out what a bond run feels like.
What happened
In its first decade the euro lowered borrowing costs for weaker members, which borrowed heavily. When 2008 exposed these debts, bond markets began to price default, and because banks held their governments' bonds and governments guaranteed the banks, the two fed each other. Greece, Ireland, Portugal, Cyprus and the Spanish banks were rescued; Italy and Spain came close to losing market access. Draghi's 'whatever it takes' in July 2012 ended the acute phase. Greece lost a quarter of its output; Spanish and Greek unemployment passed 25%.
How it unfolded
Convergence and hidden deficits (2009-04 to 2010-04, 13 months)
Post-2008 deficits of 10 to 30% of GDP (Ireland with bank guarantees), Greek statistics revised, spreads widening from near zero while the recovery in US and core markets continued.
What came next: The first Greek programme in May 2010 and the ECB's first bond purchases; contagion moved to Ireland and Portugal within a year.
Doom loop and contagion to Italy and Spain (2010-05 to 2012-07, 27 months)
Programmes for Greece, Ireland and Portugal, austerity, Greek yields above 35%, Italy and Spain above 7%, bank deposit flight from the periphery, the euro's survival priced as uncertain; US stocks fell 19% in 2011 with the US downgrade.
What came next: The ECB's promise and the OMT backstop in summer 2012 turned the spreads without a single purchase; the economic damage lasted years and Greece needed a third programme in 2015.
Whatever it takes (2012-08 to 2013-06, 11 months)
Spreads collapsed, deposit flight reversed, the euro survived; Cyprus was bailed in with depositor losses in March 2013.
What came next: A slow recovery with 25% unemployment in Spain and Greece, ECB QE in 2015, Greek programme exit only in 2018.
Slow recovery (2013-07 to 2015-12, 30 months)
Periphery yields fell toward Germany's; growth returned slowly; the ECB started QE in March 2015.
What came next: Negative rates and the search for yield; Italian banks' bad loans lingered to 2017.
Key dates
| Date | Event | Stage |
|---|---|---|
| 2009-10-20 | Greek deficit revised to 12.7% of GDP | Trigger |
| 2010-05-02 | First Greek programme; ECB bond buying follows | Policy turn |
| 2010-11-28 | Irish programme | Panic |
| 2011-05-17 | Portuguese programme | Panic |
| 2011-07 | Italian 10-year above 6%; contagion to the core | Panic |
| 2011-11 | Italy 7.5%, Spain 7.6%; governments fall | Panic |
| 2011-12 | ECB three-year LTROs, about 1 trillion euro | Policy turn |
| 2012-03 | Greek private-sector debt restructuring (PSI), the largest ever | Panic |
| 2012-07-26 | Draghi: whatever it takes | Policy turn |
| 2012-09-06 | OMT announced; spreads fall for three years | Low |
| 2013-03 | Cyprus bail-in | Aftermath |
| 2015-07-05 | Greek referendum; third programme in August | Aftermath |
By the numbers
- Euro Stoxx 50 (about -35% 2011); Athens -90%: -35% from the peak to the low
- Peak to low: 15 months
- Output, peak to trough: -25%
- Unemployment at its worst: 27.9%
- EUR/USD (1.49 to 1.20): -20%
What moved
- Fell: Greek bonds 53.5% haircut; Portuguese and Irish bonds -40% at the lows (2010 to 2012)
- Fell: periphery banks; Cyprus depositors above 100,000 euro bailed in (2010 to 2013)
- Fell: Athens -90%; Euro Stoxx banks -70% (2009 to 2012)
- Fell: euro -20% against the dollar (2011 to 2012)
- Held up or rose: German Bunds (yield to 1.2% and later below zero); US Treasuries (2010 to 2012)
- Held up or rose: gold to $1,900 in September 2011 (2010 to 2011)
- Held up or rose: buyers of periphery bonds after July 2012 (2012-08 onward)
Lessons the episode left
- A currency union without a fiscal union or lender of last resort makes sovereign debt default-risky.
- Banks holding their own sovereign's bonds create a doom loop.
- The credible backstop (OMT) ended the panic without being used; austerity without a backstop deepened it.
- Deposit flight from a currency area's weak members is the modern form of the bank run.
What this means for a reader
Signs that were visible at the time:
- Spreads within a currency union widening from zero
- Banks and governments depending on each other's credit
A common misreading: Expecting the euro to break up; the institutions were changed instead.
History gives the range of what has happened, not what happens next. The numbers above are one index at one place; other markets in the same episode moved differently.
Sources
- Baldwin and Giavazzi (2015)
- Brunnermeier, James, Landau (2016)
- ECB press releases
- FinUties crisis case file 19-euro-sovereign-debt-crisis-2010-12.md