Crises
The August 2011 US downgrade and euro stress
After the debt-ceiling standoff, S&P cut the US rating from AAA on 5 August 2011. The S&P 500 fell 6.7% on 8 August with the VIX at 48, while euro-area stress (Italy and Spain above 6%) and a weak economy added to the fall; the index lost 19.4% from April to October. Treasury yields fell to 1.7% and gold reached $1,900: the downgrade increased demand for Treasuries. Operation Twist and the ECB's long-term loans ended the episode.
The fall in numbers
- Years
- 2011
- Index
- S&P 500
- Peak
- 29 Apr 2011
- Trough
- 3 Oct 2011
- Peak to trough
- -19.4%
- Time from peak to trough
- 5.0 months
- Time to recover the peak
- 4.0 months
- Recession
- No
- Regions
- US, euro area
- Markets
- Equity index, Rates, Gold, Vol index
In one line
The US lost its AAA and its bonds rallied.
What happened
After the debt-ceiling standoff, S&P cut the US rating from AAA on 5 August 2011. The S&P 500 fell 6.7% on 8 August with the VIX at 48, while euro-area stress (Italy and Spain above 6%) and a weak economy added to the fall; the index lost 19.4% from April to October. Treasury yields fell to 1.7% and gold reached $1,900: the downgrade increased demand for Treasuries. Operation Twist and the ECB's long-term loans ended the episode.
How it unfolded
Fragile recovery (2011-01 to 2011-07, 7 months)
A recovery slowing after QE2, euro periphery spreads widening, a political standoff over the US debt ceiling.
What came next: A 17% fall in two weeks after the downgrade and euro contagion to Italy.
Downgrade and euro contagion (2011-08 to 2011-10, 3 months)
Four consecutive days of 4%+ moves, Treasury yields down to 1.7%, gold at a record, Italian yields above 7% by November.
What came next: A 30% rally into 2012 after Twist, LTROs and 'whatever it takes'.
Recovery (2011-11 to 2012-04, 6 months)
Central-bank support on both sides of the Atlantic.
What came next: The euro crisis peak in mid-2012 and its resolution.
Key dates
| Date | Event | Stage |
|---|---|---|
| 2011-04-29 | S&P peak 1,364 | Peak |
| 2011-08-02 | Debt ceiling resolved | Warning |
| 2011-08-05 | US downgraded to AA+ | Trigger |
| 2011-08-08 | S&P -6.7%; VIX 48 | Panic |
| 2011-09-06 | Gold $1,900 | Panic |
| 2011-09-21 | Operation Twist | Policy turn |
| 2011-10-03 | S&P low 1,099 (-19.4%) | Low |
| 2012-02 | High regained | Old high regained |
By the numbers
- S&P 500: -19.4% from the peak to the low
- Peak to low: 5 months
- Low back to the old high: 4 months (price only)
What moved
- Fell: S&P -19.4%; European banks -40% (2011-04 to 2011-10)
- Held up or rose: Treasuries rallied after their own downgrade (2011-08 to 2011-09)
- Held up or rose: gold to $1,900, then a four-year bear market (2011-09)
Lessons the episode left
- A downgrade of the reserve currency's sovereign raised demand for its bonds.
- Gold's 2011 peak marked the end of a 10-year run, not a start.
- Four 4% days in a row is a liquidity event; the low came within eight weeks.
What this means for a reader
Signs that were visible at the time:
- Volatility clusters: several 4% days in a row
- Haven flows into the asset that was downgraded
A common misreading: Selling Treasuries on a rating action.
History gives the range of what has happened, not what happens next. The numbers above are one index at one place; other markets in the same episode moved differently.
Sources
- Shiller, 10y, gold, VIX (open)
- FinUties crisis case file 24-other-episodes.md